This makes the 4th book I have read from this author. I guess it evens up the score. I really enjoyed both "In the Woods" and "The Likeness" and found the "The Wych Elm" so-so. Frank Mackey, a second player in those books (esp The Likeness), is front and center in this outing and really hooked my interest, as he is a pivotal character, and sure to have a deeper back story. But much like the "Wych Elm" this is more of an indulgent character back story, less an involving murder mystery. As many have said, quite simple to figure out the culprit, and the mystery was more of an after thought any how. It was mostly over-used tropes and stereo-typically Irish class divides, I will admit that I did a bit of skimming at the end. Yes, I got it, Francis loved Rosie, and some-how Ms. French believes that he is a redeemable enough character to get a second chance with Olivia. And while yes--it doesn't excuse homicide--I did find myself a bit sympathetic with the culprit. Apparently Frank only sees black and white when it comes to the behavior of others--it is only his life that should be viewed as a lighter shade of gray.

That said I will keep reading her books, in hopes that she will switch back to the police procedural mode.